Bay Ridge's bagel shop on Third Avenue, open every day from 5 AM to 8:30 PM. Everything baked right here, cream cheese blended in house, and that famous Saturday line out the door that always keeps moving.
Bagel Boy makes every bagel from scratch and blends its many varieties of cream cheese right on site. The bagels rest on baking racks before they hit the oven, on their way from dough to perfection. The Third Avenue shop is one of three Bagel Boy locations across Brooklyn and New Jersey. Just follow the smell of freshly baked bagels.
Baked here all day, never shipped in, never sitting around.
Boiled and baked here every morning, hot out of the case all day until close.
Dozens of varieties whipped up on site, including a vegan spread.
Egg and cheese on anything, plus salads, cold cuts and coffee for the road.
Bagel Wheels and Giant Heroes stacked with the best Italian imports, shipped anywhere. See the full menu.
Get delivery or pickup through Grubhub, or grab the Bagel Boy app to keep up with all three locations. Fresh bagels are a couple of taps away.
4.1 stars across 368 Yelp reviews, and a delivery crowd that keeps coming back.
"Solid bagels and I was very impressed. The cream cheese spread was plentiful, lox generous and avocados enough for a well rounded sandwich."
"Best bagels in town. I have been a customer of Bagel Boy for years and it was love at first bite. Bagels are always hot and fresh and baked to absolute perfection."
"If you know Bay Ridge, you know Bagel Boy. From fresh, hot bagels to delicious spreads, one of the best bagel places in Brooklyn."
The Bay Ridge shop is at 8002 3rd Ave, Brooklyn NY 11209, open Monday to Sunday from 5:00 AM to 8:30 PM, call (718) 748-0366. Sheepshead Bay: 1602 Avenue Z, Brooklyn NY 11235, open daily 5:00 AM to 9:30 PM, call (718) 332-3444. Old Bridge NJ: 2329 County Rd 516, Old Bridge NJ 08857, open daily 5:00 AM to 8:00 PM, call (732) 679-5020.
Yes. All baking is done on premises, fresh all day, every day. The bagels rest on baking racks before baking, then head straight to the counter.
Plenty. Many varieties of cream cheese are blended on site, and there is a vegan cream cheese spread too.
We would love to. Bagel Boy caters affairs of any size, and ships Bagel Wheels and Giant Heroes stacked with top Italian imports and domestic cold cuts.
Yes. Order delivery or pickup on Grubhub, or use the Bagel Boy mobile app to stay in the loop with all three locations.
Plenty: breakfast sandwiches, salads, cold cuts, coffee, and the works. The full menu is one tap away on our menu page.
Third Avenue, Bay Ridge. Open every day 5 AM to 8:30 PM, and we would love to cater your next affair.
Order Now
Order on Grubhub
Order on Uber Eats